On the train this morning, I heard a classic exchange between two women (and it's always two women).
The first one mentioned something about picking up a self-defense item -- I think it was pepper spray. Her friend responded with that ancient bit of folk wisdom:
"You shouldn't do that. It can be taken away from you and used against you."
Who invented this atrocious piece of poor advice? Was it some guy who felt women shouldn't know how to fight, or just couldn't be bothered to explain how a knife or other weapon worked?
Think of it this way. All things being equal, this idea suggests that the world is a place where anyone is in danger the moment they pick up any weapon, because it might be "taken away and used against them." Does that strike you as sane? Try putting it in context:
The Scene: June 14, 1994. Allied forces continue to advance into Western Europe. A small patrol of American troops happen to run across a downed German pilot wandering the countryside.
Sgt Jones: Private Smith! Capture that man!
Pvt Smith: I can't, sir. It's just too terrifying.
Sgt Jones: What are you on about, Smith? He's unarmed!
Pvt Smith: I know, sir. But he might take my rifle away from me and use it against me!
Silly, right? Right.
So we don't live in that world. Soldiers use guns, because they are a tool that gives you a huge advantage in a fight. The risk is not in having the weapon taken away from you; it's in not having brought a weapon when the other guy remembered to bring his.
So what's that advice about, then?
The message of this advice is that you, the woman who is being told this, are so helpless that there's just no point in trying to equip yourself with some self-defense item. A taser, pepper spray, a knife -- it won't help. It'll be taken away from you, and you'll lose. The core message there is you are a victim, and there's nothing you can do about it.
Makes you a little angry, right?
It's bundled in with other winners like "Don't fight back, it'll only make things worse."
Here's an alternative message:
Pick up some pepper spray, a taser, a knife or other device if you feel like it. Learn how it works, learn its limitations, and have a backup plan. Do fight back, because it's a proven fact that fighting back doesn't "make it worse". In fact, in the specific case of sexual assault, women who try to fight (and you don't have to be any kind of expert at all!) successfully avoid rape much more often than those who don't try to fight.
I'm looking forward to a world where women are not handed an issue of Cosmo that explains their deficiencies while their friends tell them they're helpless.